Pa. Justices Reject Bid to Require Arbitration of Case Against Toll Bros. Over Construction Flaws
April 23, 2020 | The Legal IntelligencerThe Legal Intelligencer reports on a significant legal victory secured by Horn Williamson on behalf of Pennsylvania homeowners pursuing construction defect claims against Toll Brothers.
The Pennsylvania Supreme Court denied Toll Brothers’ petition for allowance of appeal in Porter v. Toll Brothers, leaving intact a Superior Court ruling that allows 30 lawsuits brought by subsequent purchasers of water-damaged homes to proceed in state court rather than through arbitration.
The decision also has implications for additional homeowners. On April 21, 2020, another Pennsylvania Superior Court panel allowed seven more cases against Toll Brothers to proceed in state court, relying on the earlier Porter ruling.
“This is a significant victory for our clients, who have endured so many sleepless nights over the condition of and repair costs of their homes, which are usually a family’s largest asset,” said Jennifer Horn, founding partner of Horn Williamson, in a statement quoted by The Legal Intelligencer. “This decision puts an end to Toll Brothers’ attempts to draw out this long-running legal battle and enables these homeowners to pursue the justice they deserve.”
By: Max Mitchell
The high court’s decision lets stand the frontline appeals court’s ruling that secondary buyers were not bound by original warranty agreements—which included mandatory arbitration provisions—between the real estate developer and the first purchasers of the homes.
Dozens of lawsuits against the home-building company Toll Brothers Inc. are set to play out in state court after the Pennsylvania Supreme Court rejected the company’s move to corral the cases into arbitration.