What Lurks Beneath: Protecting Your Home and Legal Rights from Unseen Construction Deficiencies
September 21, 2021 | Community Assets MagazineBy: Nikolas D. Regalbuto
Exterior cladding may not be something you give a lot of attention. However, this building component essentially serves as your home’s skin. Cladding provides weather protection along with a degree of thermal insulation. While cladding is a system of materials layered on top of one another, most homeowners are only aware of the outermost layer that is visible. These outermost layers often consist of stucco, vinyl siding and fiber cement siding. Unfortunately, these materials can hide problems lurking beneath within the other components of the cladding system.
The unseen problems within cladding systems often result in water damage and mold growth.
Stucco was widely used within our region and, when properly installed, serves as an excellent cladding system. Proper installation requires rain barriers beneath the stucco layer that will allow the stucco surface to properly dry. When working correctly, the rainwater will filter out of the walls while the wall interiors remain free of lingering moisture. A rain barrier is not the only unseen component acting in unison with stucco in an exterior wall. There should also be building paper and flashing installed around windows and doors. Without building paper and flashing, the risk of leaks increases to a great degree. Additional items such as weep screeds, gutters and many other trade practices are used to ensure the stucco cladding system is fully effective and can properly shield the inside of a home from the outside elements.
When installed improperly, a cladding system can actually trap, as opposed to shed, water. A failing system collecting water can cause a multitude of problems, including fostering mold growth, rot and water infiltration to the interior of the home. Often these issues remain undiscovered until an invasive inspection is conducted or significant damage has presented itself. Some homeowners have experienced wall cladding that has not been flashed or does not provide for any breathing room for the stucco exterior. Sometimes the layer of stucco applied is far too thin and does not meet building code requirements or has begun to crack as a consequence of being installed improperly. Various homeowners are even familiar with a bulging effect that stucco experiences when trapped water starts to reshape the outer layer of the wall.
These deficiencies have no relation to maintenance or upkeep by the homeowner. Deficiencies within cladding systems are almost always traced back to original construction. In many instances, our law firm has observed cladding problems caused by the deliberate cutting of corners to increase profit. Once the stucco or other siding is applied, it may take years before a homeowner can even realize the existence of a problem.
Heavy staining and black spots are common signs that stucco was improperly installed. The growth spots often occur where walls intersect with the roof, as well as around windows and doors. These are signs that you may be experiencing mold growth or rot within the walls of the home due to the cladding not effectively draining water. Wall rot can cause condensation on the inside of walls as well. Of course, leaks are one of the most common issues arising from deficiencies in the exterior layers of a home.
Homeowners should not be responsible for addressing the builder’s deficient construction. Instead, many turn to litigation in order to secure the necessary repairs or the funds necessary to perform the repairs. Since damage caused by deficient cladding systems often takes many years to manifest, homeowners need to pay particular attention to the statute of repose and the statute of limitations, which can serve to bar a homeowner’s legal remedies.
A statute of repose imposes a time limit within which construction-related claims can be brought against those parties lawfully performing or furnishing the design, planning, supervision or observation of the construction, or construction of any improvement to real property. In Pennsylvania, the statute of repose is 12 years, but an exception may apply to some cases extending the time limit an additional two years. New Jersey’s statute of repose is only 10 years.
The statute of limitations differs from the statute of repose and provides separate protections for those involved in the homebuilding process. While the statute of repose is applied from the time the construction is completed, the statute of limitations does not begin to run until the homeowner becomes aware, or by exercise of reasonable diligence should have become aware, of the defect. This concept is often referred to as the “discovery rule.”
The following hypothetical further illustrates the similarities and differences between the statute of repose and statute of limitations. If a Pennsylvania homeowner bought a finished house in 2005 and, despite her reasonable due diligence, only discovered the defects in 2020, the statute of limitations would not begin to run until the discovery in 2020. However, the homeowner’s claims would likely be barred under the statute of repose.
Given the foregoing, do not delay when you suspect problems with your cladding. Upon observing any such potential signs of cladding problems, contact a licensed design or building professional who can properly diagnose the suspected problems. You should also consider retaining legal counsel who can help guide you through this process.
About the Author
Nikolas D. Regalbuto was an associate attorney at Horn Williamson, where he divided his time between the firm’s construction defect and community association practice groups, with an emphasis on dispute resolution.
Originally published in the September/October 2021 issue of Community Assets magazine. Read the original article (Page 26).