‘Pay Was Bad, Hours Weren’t Terrific, Computers Broke Down,’ and Justice Was Served: Business Judge Gene D. Cohen’s 20 Years on Philly Bench
January 20, 2020 | The Philadelphia InquirerJoseph N. DiStefano of The Philadelphia Inquirer interviewed Horn Williamson inside general counsel Judge Gene D. Cohen (Ret.) for his Philly Deals column, exploring Gene’s distinguished legal career, his two terms on the Philadelphia Court of Common Pleas and some of the most consequential decisions he made during his years on the bench.
The wide-ranging profile examines Gene’s approach to judicial independence, government accountability and transparency, including his refusal to approve a settlement involving Pennsylvania public pension investments that he believed lacked sufficient transparency. Discussing the confidential mediation process, Gene explained that the negotiations focused on reaching a financial agreement rather than establishing responsibility for the losses. “It was all about getting to ‘Yes’ from a dollar point of view,” he said, emphasizing his refusal to “sign a blank check.”
The article also explores Gene’s perspectives on binding arbitration, judicial ethics, grand jury proceedings and political influence in the courts. Throughout the interview, Gene reflects on the importance of independent judgment and the responsibility judges have to uphold the public’s trust, even when their decisions are unpopular or politically sensitive.
Back in the 1960s, Gene D. Cohen says, he was an unlikely Army police captain — three inches shorter than the rule book limit and “the only Jew in the battalion” — but that’s where he was assigned after Penn State ROTC.
He came home to Philly, where, amid his long law career, he presided over major commercial cases, pulling two stints as an unlikely Common Pleas Court judge: was tapped by Gov. Bob Casey and retained by voters (1988 to 2005) as a replacement for elected judges snared in the Roofers Union campaign-cash scandal; and was returned to the bench as an appointed senior judge (2016-19).
“The pay was bad, the hours weren’t terrific, the computers broke down,” he said, so at 77 he gave it up again, after delivering last year’s Duffield House ruling, ordering the city to repay landlords $50 million to reverse an unconstitutional tax increase. (The city has appealed.)